sixtyandme logo
We are community supported and may earn a commission when you buy through links on our site. Learn more

Who Should Chase Whom in Dating?

By Michele Burghardt April 10, 2025 Dating

There seems to be some confusion surrounding who should be the pursuer when you’re dating at this stage of life. Men love women who make the first move, and many women love the feeling of being pursued. So how do you meld these two concepts?

Make the First Move

One of the main reasons men love women to make the first move is that they are deathly afraid of rejection. This is something that men have been dealing with since puberty, and they want to avoid at all costs. So much that in some cases it keeps them from taking any type of action at all.

Women always set the pace of the relationship and once you understand men’s fear, you can create an experience that will be a win-win for both of you, and it’s not that difficult to do.

So many of my female clients tell me they are tired of driving the bus by themselves. They are looking for a man with a plan so they can lean back and have more fun. They did all the planning when they were younger, and they want someone with whom to share this responsibility now.

I totally get it and feel the same way. It’s a good rule of thumb too, because once you take control of a relationship, it’s almost impossible to give it back. If you start managing your dates at the beginning, you’ll be managing your dates throughout your entire relationship should one develop.

Read more: Understanding Compatibility in Early Dating: What Really Matters.

The Choice Is Yours

So how can you lean back, which is feminine energy, by the way, and still be the first one to reach out? It’s not as complicated as you may think.

It doesn’t matter if you’re dating online or meeting men in real life, you can still make the first move without taking control of the relationship by simply creating an opportunity for the man to step up. Now that you know how serious men feel about rejection, you know you could be waiting a long time if you wait for him to approach you. I almost always reach out first when I’m dating online.

I empower my clients so they feel comfortable doing the ‘picking’ rather than wait around to be ‘picked’ by a man who may or may not be a good fit for them. When you do the picking, you get to choose who you invite into your world, and it saves you time and frustration.

But Let Him Plan

The way I teach my clients to do this is simply to show their interest, and then lean back and let the man plan the date. This is what it sounds like when you’re texting or talking on the phone.

“Bob, it’s been great texting with you, and I feel like you’re someone I’d like to talk to. I’m happy to send you my number, what do you think?”

“I’ve really enjoyed chatting with you tonight and love that we have so many things in common. I’d be interested in learning more about you over a cup of coffee. How does that sound to you?”

These simple statements show him you’re interested and eliminate his fear of rejection while they volley the next steps back to him. Once he says, “Sure,” then you can simply tell him what days you’re available and ask him to pick a time and place to meet.

If he has trouble coming up with a location, some women offer a couple of options while other women simply tell them nicely to figure it out. If you give him options, you still want to want to leave the final decisions and planning up to him.

“I like ____, ____ or _____ and I’ll leave in your hands to pick the best place.”

Again, you’re creating the opportunity for him to take the lead. If you like being responsible for everything, you would probably simply give him a time and place to meet. This may be a little off-putting for him if he’s a masculine energy man. This type of man likes having a job to do and may feel a little out-of-sync as a result.

Read more: What Do Single Men Over 60 Really Want? This Dating Coach’s Advice Will Surprise You!(Video)

What if He’s Not Taking the Lead?

So, you made the first move. You showed interest, sent the message, or suggested meeting for coffee. But now… crickets. Or maybe he responded, but he’s vague about making plans, keeps postponing, or always puts the ball back in your court.

This is where it’s important to notice the difference between someone who’s just shy and someone who isn’t that interested – or isn’t ready to date. If a man is genuinely interested, he’ll find a way to follow through. He might need a little nudge at first, but he won’t leave all the planning to you every time.

If you find yourself chasing him down to get anything on the calendar or constantly trying to keep the conversation going, it might be time to step back. You’re looking for a partner, not another project.

Give it a little space. If he picks up the thread and starts putting in some effort, great. If not, you have your answer. Sometimes letting go of lukewarm interest clears the path for someone who’s actually ready to show up.

Read more:The 5 Types You Should Never Date.

This Is Our Time

This is a beautiful chapter of life. We’re old enough to know what we want, and confident enough to ask for it. This is an empowering time, but it does come with some responsibility. We do need to be considerate of the men we invite in our lives. They are much more romantic and sensitive than we’ve been led to believe and words do matter.

If you want more step-by-step coaching so you can date with clarity and confidence, check out
The Perfect Dating Guide for Women over 50.

Read more: How to Date Differently in 2025 So You Can Find Love.

Editor’s Note: Article updated by Sixty & Me.

Let’s Have a Conversation:

Do you approach men first, or do you prefer to be chased? If you make the first move, what do you say? How has this strategy worked for you?

Subscribe
Notify of
guest
11 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Randi

First of all, in your first statement about the texting, then having a phone conversation and offering him your number, he already has the phone number since you are both texting.

When I was dating, before meeting my current husband 13 years ago, I always left it up to the man to make plans for the first meeting. If he doesn’t step up to the plate and ask ME, then I know he’s not serious about meeting and he’s just a player. Yes, it’s OK to offer your e-mail address or phone number first before he does but when it comes time for planning the meeting, I leave it up to them. And I always have to have a phone call before the meeting. I never go blindly without speaking to the guy first.

Michele Burghardt

Hi Randi, I was referring to text on an app first, but I undertand your sentiments completely. Yes, I agree with you, when a man steps up to the plate, you definitely know he’s interested. Thanks for your comment. Wishing you continued happiness! xxoo Michele

Lin

I am happy to be the one that first sends a ‘smile’ on a dating site. Most men don’t respond because they looking for younger women. I had one lovely man interested and he was two years younger and we had a wonderful 3 dates, But he died quickly from esophageal cancer and after the 3rd date, chose not to continue dating. We kept in touch and he died just a few weeks ago. Then I started corresponding with a man that was just looking for a friend and that fit my needs perfectly. We eat out, go to plays, concerts, and museums, but nothing sexual is involved. Even if I find a lover at a later time, this current man will always be my friend.

Michele Burghardt

Hi Lin, I’m so glad you found the type of relationship that you were looking for. That’s what it’s all about and I’m happy for you. Thanks for the nice comment. xxoo Michele

Barbara

I reached out to a man on a dating site. We had our first date. I sent him a text message telling him thank you for lunch and I look forward to getting to know him better. He responded that he felt the same way and that we seem perfectly matched. Well, that was three weeks ago. Do I reach out again or just let it go? I really like him.

Michele Burghardt

Hi Barbara, getting to date two can be as challenging as getting to the date #1. What I recommend is that you keep reaching out to high-quality men so you don’t glob all our energy on your previous lunch date. Then drop him ONE fun, flirty message like “Knock, knock, knock, did you run off and join the circus” and then move on if he doesn’t respond. If you want more on this and dating in general check out my book at http://www.dategreatguys.com/store. Good luck my friend!

Joyce

I am from the generation, like most of us, where it was not lady-like to call a “boy”. To this day, I prefer to be chased and have the option of saying yes or no to any advances.

Michele Burghardt

HI Joyce, I’m with you. That why I teach my clients to offer men the opportunity to chase them. It’s let’s them know they are interested but volleys the action back to them. Thanks for reading & happy Thanksgiving. xxoo Michele

Stephanie Bryant

I do not like doing the picking because if I don’t get a response, I feel rejected. I’d rather someone reach out to me and then I can decide if I want to respond.

Michele Burghardt

Hi Stephanie, I know I responded to your comment via email but I wanted the other ladies to see my response so I’m reposting here.

Remember that not all the men online are still active. None of the dating sites delete profiles when a subscription runs out, so you may be messaging men who are no longer onlline. Zoosk says a 1% response rate is good. That is 1 out of 100.

Hope this helps you understand the online game a bit better. And consider that rejection is simply feedback and redirection. He simply isn’t the right fit for you! You deserve to have the right man in your life!

Thanks for your comment, and Happy Thanksgiving. xxoo Michele

The Author

Michele Burghardt is an author, speaker, and dating coach for women 50 and over with 20 + years of experience in the self-help area. She believes loving yourself is the first step to finding love. You can learn more about her transformational coaching style and her book at www.DateGreatGuys.com.

You Might Also Like