If you ask an AI chatbot whether you should claim Social Security at 62 or wait until 70, within a few seconds it provides a response. That response may include pros and cons and maybe even a recommendation, all of which might sound reasonable.
But is the answer correct for your personal situation? And would you know if it left something out because you didn’t think to ask a different question?
As a financial planner, this is my biggest concern about people relying on AI to make important money decisions. Don’t get me wrong, AI has real uses, and I use it in my practice. But I’ve sometimes asked the same question in different ways using a disposable chat and received markedly different answers. Knowing financial, tax, and estate planning rules helps me recognize when something doesn’t seem quite right.
I think of AI a little like Wikipedia. Both can be great starting points to learn terms and figure out what to research next. But I wouldn’t use either as my final authority on an important financial decision.
If you want to understand the difference between a traditional IRA and a Roth IRA, AI can do a good job explaining the basics. You can also ask follow-up questions without feeling embarrassed.
But I draw a line between asking how something works and what action I should take.
Suppose you ask AI: “Should I convert $50,000 of my traditional IRA to a Roth IRA this year?”
AI might explain the benefits of a Roth conversion and hopefully mention that the amount converted is generally taxable. But did it actually answer your question?
Someone more familiar with retirement planning might ask how the conversion affects federal and state taxes, Social Security taxation, future required minimum distributions, and Medicare premiums.
Take Medicare’s income-related monthly adjustment amount (IRMAA). Higher income can result in higher Part B and Part D premiums. Social Security generally uses your modified adjusted gross income from two years earlier (with some exceptions for qualifying life changes) to determine your IRMAA adjustment. Unlike marginal federal income tax brackets, IRMAA thresholds work in steps. Even a dollar over a threshold can move you into a higher premium bracket.
Someone familiar with these rules may recognize what’s missing from an AI answer and ask follow-up questions.
Although AI has improved, it can still provide incorrect information. It might use outdated tax rules, miss an exception, or confidently make an assertion that its cited source doesn’t support. What frustrates me is how confidently it can answer, even when it shouldn’t.
And even a correct answer may not be appropriate for your situation. For example, delaying Social Security typically increases your monthly benefit, but that doesn’t necessarily mean you should wait until 70. Does AI know about your health, marital status, or whether you need money sooner?
I advise against entering Social Security numbers, account numbers, passwords, or financial documents containing identifying details into AI chatbots. But your personal circumstances still matter when making financial decisions.
After receiving an answer, dig deeper. Ask, “What am I overlooking?” or “What assumptions are you making?” (Although AI might make up new assumptions.)
You could also ask, “What are the top two to five questions I should ask a financial planner or tax professional before proceeding, and why?”
I suggest limiting the number because AI can generate as many questions as you request. What’s more important is understanding why those questions matter.
For important information, I’d also check original sources, such as the IRS, Social Security Administration, Medicare, or retirement plan documents, rather than assuming AI interpreted them correctly.
I’m not suggesting you need professional advice every time you want to understand something. But Roth conversions, pension elections, and selling appreciated investments can affect your taxes and cash flow. Some decisions are difficult to reverse, while others are impossible to undo.
Depending on the issue, a financial planner, attorney, or tax professional can help see how the pieces fit together by asking appropriate follow-up questions. AI can help you prepare for those conversations.
That’s my suggestion: use AI as a starting point, but don’t assume its confident answers fit your unique situation. And if a professional doesn’t seem to be addressing your concerns, consider getting a second opinion.
Have you asked AI about money, finances, or retirement? Did you leave the conversation feeling better informed or wondering what else you should have asked? Have you acted on an AI answer, and was the outcome what you expected?