sixtyandme logo
We are community supported and may earn a commission when you buy through links on our site. Learn more

Sisterhood of the Supernatural: Would You Go on a Ghost Tour?

By Amy Muschik November 17, 2026 Travel

Remember those shows featuring 20-something men running around shadowy buildings with flashy gadgets? For decades, popular culture painted ghost hunting as a young man’s game. But stepping aboard a motorcoach along the Haunted History Trail of New York State, I quickly discovered a very different reality.

I recently travelled on a sold-out Haunted History Trail tour through Upstate New York, guided by television investigator Brian J. Cano. The demographic was an eye-opener: nearly 70% of modern-day ghost tour attendees are women, with many being vibrant, inquisitive women over the age of 60.

Surprisingly (at least to me), mature female travelers are driving the growing movement of dark heritage and ghost tourism. Armed with open minds, keen curiosity, and a deep respect for local lore, these women are demonstrating that the pursuit of history and mystery knows no age limit.

Safety, Sisterhood, and the Comfort of Curated Travel

This begs the question: why are women filling these tours to places of reputed hauntings?

For solo female travelers and groups of friends alike, exploring dark, isolated, or unfamiliar historic sites at night can feel intimidating or unsafe to navigate alone. Curated, guide-led itineraries solve this completely. By taking care of the logistics, eliminating late-night driving on unfamiliar rural roads, securing access to avoid trespassing, providing comfortable transportation, regular washroom breaks, and organizing meals; operators make fringe travel completely approachable.

The resulting camaraderie is immediate and genuine. Women came from far and wide, traveling from as far as California, for a wide variety of personal reasons.

I met a woman in her 70s, a true believer, traveling with her husband, who happily came along because he enjoys the history. Another traveling with her adult daughter, sharing a unique mother-daughter adventure. Another little group of 60 somethings were cousins and lifelong friends, sharing an unconventional girls’ getaway, while the solo women in the group were quickly embraced by fellow travelers as they shared the experience.

 As TV ambassador Brian Cano observed during our trip, the experience becomes far more about community than eerie encounters: “I find it’s less about the dead and more about the living… It’s a very social thing. We ate together, we rode on the bus together, we shared the experience.”

Women who step on board as strangers depart as lasting friends.

History First: The Appeal of “Edutainment”

Tour operators like the Haunted History Trail of New York State, which now encompasses 83 historic locations across the state, recognize that mature women approach the supernatural with a grounded, thoughtful perspective.

Rather than relying on sensationalism, the trail operates on an “edutainment” philosophy. Ghost stories serve as an inviting gateway to authentic historical education and community preservation. Guests explore local architecture, regional museums, learn of wartime sacrifices, and industrial heritage, intertwined with the local ghost stories that pepper that history, even at scenic daytime stops like the Maid of the Mist in Niagara Falls. Highly anticipated are the hands on participation in night-time communication and investigative sessions.

Though as experienced travelers quickly learn, ghosts do not follow a nighttime schedule. Unexplained occurrences, subtle atmosphere shifts, and historical stories unfold just as naturally under the afternoon sun as they do after dark.

Historic Venues and the Women Who Keep Their Stories Alive

Over the course of two separate trips to the trail, I discovered the true heart of the trail lies in the historic venues themselves, many of which are owned, restored, and stewarded by inspiring female proprietors.

Iron Island Museum (Buffalo, NY)

Housed in an 1895 wood-frame church and former funeral home, Iron Island is dedicated to preserving the working-class railroad heritage of Buffalo’s Lovejoy neighborhood. The museum was founded by Marge, a remarkable woman now in her 90s, who still welcomes guests and shares memories of the neighborhood, the spirits of young children like Jimmy who remain in the building, and the historic church altar that inexplicably gives off a smoky odor, even though it was acquired from another church days before the church burned. Beside her is Lorraine, who leads the museum’s paranormal explorations.

Iron Island museum – military tribute display. Image credit: Amy Muschik

Their hospitality is unforgettable. On a return visit, Marge and Lorraine welcomed me like family, inviting me to place a pin on their world map alongside visitors from across the globe, before sending me off with a warm hug. Beyond their warmth lies profound stewardship. When paranormal sessions and spirit interactions (including audio EVPs from the cantankerous ghost of a soldier named Edgar) led investigators to search the basement, they discovered the unclaimed cremated remains of 24 military veterans stored in paint cans. Marge and Lorraine then spearheaded the effort to organize full military honors and a 25-motorcycle procession to secure a dignified burial at Bath National Cemetery.

The Western Block (Lockport, NY)

Perched along the historic Erie Canal, this complex features 1825 stone structures and 1903 brick industrial buildings once powered by canal water channels. Owner Heather, an architectural designer who purchased the property to fulfill a childhood dream, is converting the sprawling site into a vibrant community arts and cultural center. While balancing daytime art classes and community outreach, Heather hosts evening history tours where visitors explore former industrial shops, examine 19th-century business ledgers and participate in traditional group sessions electronic voice phenomenon, and table tipping.

Western block – nightime investigations. Image credit: Amy Muschik

Pratt Event Center (Albion, NY)

An interconnected complex of three 19th-century structures, the Pratt Event Center features a magnificent 1882 Grand Opera House and a Civil War Grand Army of the Republic (GAR) veterans’ hall. Former owners Judy Koehler and her husband Mike Bonafede restored the complex over a 22-year labor of love before passing the torch to new owner Taylor McCabe.

Pratt Event Center – Opera house stage. Image credit: Amy Muschik.

Today, Judy and Mike remain deeply involved, guiding tours and telling the building’s rich historical and haunted stories. Sitting in the back of the partially restored theater chatting with Judy, I realized the building itself is like an onion, with layers of time peeling back to reveal history in sections here and there, with older eras showing through from beneath. For mature women, it serves as a powerful metaphor for our own lives: how we have occupied many changing roles over time while keeping bits of who we were, who we have been, and who we are still visibly shining through.

Pratt event center – boards reveal layers of history. Image credit: Amy Muschik.

Ivy League Psychic Academy / Rhodes House (Dunkirk, NY)

Built in 1882, the historic Rhodes House boasts extraordinary hand-carved French woodwork. After serving for 55 years as a prominent funeral home, the business was shut down in scandal. The mansion sat abandoned for over a decade until psychic medium and female entrepreneur Ivy Rivera rescued it.

Ivy League Psychic Academy – exterior sign. Image credit: Amy Muschik.

Ivy chose to honor the building’s complex past rather than remodeling it away, leaving historic carpets, original pocket doors, and the old body lift intact. When asked why women dominate psychic education and heritage tours, Ivy notes that women are naturally in touch with their emotions and open to exploring the unseen, whereas men are often more guarded. Today, revenue from guided tours and intuitive classes directly funds the costs and ongoing restoration of this Victorian gem.

Ivy League – beautiful woodwork interior. Image credit: Amy Muschik.

Winery at Marjim Manor (Appleton, NY)

Situated just off the shores of Lake Ontario in Appleton, NY, this mid-1800s estate winery blends Victorian architecture, local fruit winemaking, and rich folklore. Proprietor Margo Sue purchased the property to pursue her dream of a winery, but upon discovering local ghost lore, specifically the famous legend surrounding occurrences on Thursdays at 3:00 PM, she warmly embraced it. Today, Margo offers fruit wine tastings, high teas, and historical storytelling, proving that local mystery and local agriculture can make a delightful pairing.

Winery at Marjim manor – front of the estate. Image credit: Amy Muschik.

A Journey of Discovery

Ghost tourism for women over 60 is not about chasing shadows in the dark; it is about honoring human history, cherishing architectural heritage, and celebrating the joy of lifelong discovery with like-minded companions.

By offering safe, well-curated journeys that connect travelers with passionate proprietors, the Haunted History Trail of New York State has unlocked a meaningful way for mature women to explore the past, proving that the Sisterhood of the Supernatural is here to stay.

Let’s Chat:

What’s your favorite haunted house/mansion story? Have you been on a ghost tour? Do you think there’s much history to be learned on a ghost tour and what would interest you the most?

Subscribe
Notify of
guest
0 Comments
Newest
Oldest Most Voted

The Author

Amy Muschik is a Canadian travel writer and photographer who goes looking for the history, mystery and good stories behind a destination. A member of the North American Travel Journalists Association (NATJA) and the International VR Photography Association (IVRPA), she also creates 360° virtual tours and stock photography. Follow her adventures at www.travmedia.com/amymuschik.

You Might Also Like