sixtyandme logo
We are community supported and may earn a commission when you buy through links on our site. Learn more

The Holiday Tradition I’ve Outgrown and Still Haven’t Given Up

By Elaine Belansky November 16, 2026 Lifestyle

One Christmas, my two daughters each asked Santa for a baby doll. One wanted a blonde baby dressed in pink. The other, who I think was testing Santa by then, wanted a brunette baby in green.

I couldn’t find either one. So I bought several dolls, opened the packages, dressed each baby in the requested color and resealed them perfectly in their original packaging.

I’m Jewish, and for years I was the one making Santa happen at Christmas. These days I’m trying to give up a holiday tradition of my own, and it’s turning out to be harder than doll surgery.

Santa and I Had Very High Standards

When I was growing up, Christmas Eve meant Chinese food, as it did for many Jewish families. My dad’s contribution to the holiday was “Let’s make a fire in the fireplace so Santa doesn’t get confused.” That fire was my one taste of Santa.

Then for many years, we spent Christmas with my ex-husband’s Catholic parents, and I was in charge of Santa’s gifts. I loved putting out cookies with my girls and making sure they were gone by morning. I never had that as a kid, and it was fun to see my daughters have it.

It also felt strange to be the Jewish mom running Santa. Part of me kept asking, why am I doing this, and who am I for doing this? Looking back, I wanted to create some magic for my girls, and I wanted my in-laws to enjoy it with their grandchildren. I didn’t want anyone to be disappointed. Apparently, that meant performing surgery on baby dolls.

At home we celebrated Hanukkah, and there I set a standard of my own. I wanted my girls’ eyes to pop when they saw their gifts, so I’d choose three different wrapping papers, wrap all 16 gifts as perfectly as I could, and finish each one with a bow. It was a feast for the eyes, and a lot of work. True to my last-minute nature, I’d do it all in one late night, at the peak of my end-of-semester workload.

My daughters still talk about how fun it was to see all those gifts. That one was about getting it right, and nobody was asking for it but me.

My daughters are grown now, and those years of Santa and Hanukkah gifts are behind me. But there’s another holiday tradition I’ve kept going for 20 years, and I’m ready for it to end.

The Yes I’m Ready to Give Up

For about 20 years, I’ve hosted a lunch on Rosh Hashanah, the Jewish New Year, for friends from my Jewish community. I’d be at temple in the morning, so I set the oven to come on by itself and left services early to get home in time for the last-minute prep.

It was a lovely way to bring our community into our home. It felt warm and joyful to have our circle of friends join us after services. The children ran around and played, and the adults talked about the rabbi’s sermon and enjoyed each other’s company.

For the first 10 years, my then-husband and I shared the work. After that, I kept the tradition going on my own in my new home. I got the extra chairs out the night before and set the table before I left for services. When everyone went home, I took out all the trash and put the house back together.

Somewhere along the way, though, I outgrew it, and now it feels more like a burden than a joy. I want to be done.

Why One Email Is So Hard to Send

I’ve since remarried, and my husband and I have been abroad over Rosh Hashanah the past two years, so I didn’t host. You’d think that would make it easy to pass the job along. It hasn’t. I still haven’t sent the email telling my friends I’m ready to stop having everyone over.

I feel a little guilty about that, as if the lunch is my responsibility because I’m the designated one. But after all these years, I’d really like it to be someone else’s turn.

Some of us rehearse a no in the shower as though we’re preparing to testify before Congress. For me, it’s one short email that still hasn’t gone out.

Going Big Is Fine When You Choose It

Before you decide I’ve given up on hosting, you should know about my Passover. I fly in gefilte fish from New York (the shipping costs more than the fish) and bring out the china and the crystal. It’s exhausting, and I love making it special.

Passover and the Rosh Hashanah lunch both take a lot of work. What separates them is which kind of yes each one is. There’s “I love doing this, even though it’s a lot of work,” and there’s “I’ve always done this, so I keep doing it, even though I’m no longer sure I want to.” The difference is whether I’m still choosing it.

That doesn’t make the Rosh Hashanah lunches a mistake. For a long time, I was happy to host. But something I once enjoyed has become a burden, and the arrangement isn’t going to change by itself. Somebody has to say so, and in my case, that’s me.

I think retirement is a good time to look at the roles we’ve carried for years and ask which ones we still want.

One Question to Ask This Season

Pick one thing you do every year: the dish you always bring, the cards you always send, the gathering you always pull together, the group you’ve always organized. Then ask yourself:

If I weren’t already the one who did this, would I volunteer for it this year?

When I ask it about Passover, the answer is yes. When I ask it about the Rosh Hashanah lunch, the answer is no.

If your answer comes easily, keep doing it and enjoy it. If you hesitate, you may have found a yes you’re keeping out of habit.

I’ve decided I’m done hosting the Rosh Hashanah lunch. After 20 years, I know what I want. Now I have to tell my friends.

Find Out What’s Behind Your Yeses

If there’s something you keep doing because you’ve always been the one who does it, the next question is why you keep saying yes.

I created a free three-minute quiz, Why Did I Say Yes to That?, to help you explore what’s influencing those decisions.

You’ll discover which of five common patterns you recognize in yourself, where that pattern can get in your way, and one practical thing to try first.

There are 15 quick questions, and you’ll see your result immediately.

When a few friends tried the quiz before it launched, one texted me back, “I have work to do, lol.”

👉 Take the free quiz: Why Did I Say Yes to That?

Let’s Have a Conversation:

What’s one thing you’ve always done that you’d love to be someone else’s turn?

Subscribe
Notify of
guest
0 Comments
Newest
Oldest Most Voted

Tags

The Author

Elaine Belansky, PhD, is a retirement transition coach who helps women design the life side of retirement. A former professor and public health expert, she blends science-backed tools with deep empathy to guide women through identity shifts, purpose discovery, and finding what’s next. Sign up for her weekly newsletter, The Bold Retirement Dispatch.

You Might Also Like